French Immigration

                   Carteresident

Like other foreigners I had to go through the French immigration process to have my carte de resident (green card.) Because I was married to a Frenchman the paperwork to receive residence in France, was considered more of a formality than a daunting procedure to be legal in the country. Nevertheless, it was a real eye opening experience, and one that still haunts me when I hear about immigration….

                   Resident_carte

With my back pack full of legal French documents and less than ten French words in my pocket, I went to the Prefecture to apply for my carte de resident. Standing in line, waiting with hundreds of other immigrants I realized I was not alone in feeling nervous. My eyes searched the crowd for a friend, someone who I might shot the breeze with….but without a common language between us, we could only share a small smile of encouragement.

                   French_papers

There was a guard at the entrance door. She grabbed my papers, and started to bark something in French. I didn’t know what she was saying. Luckily I understand sign language, as she pointed to the photo machine; I needed a black and white, non-smiling photo of myself. Not a happy one, in color like I had in hand. (Look at the photo of me up above…wide-eyed, looking like a boy, who is about to wet her pants.)

                   French_carte_de_resident

Walking into the small airless waiting room I saw the whole world gathered there. Fourteen chairs for a few hundred people. No water, not bathroom. There were elderly people, young people, pregnant women and small children. I stood there wishing I could do something to change the situation. Each of us had a number and waited our turn. After waiting eight hours my turn finally arrived. The clerk, who looked like she had never smiled in her entire life, looked at me like I was a murderer trying to ask for a knife. It wasn’t easy.

I felt angry. Angry that people should treat people as rudely as I had seen in the last eight hours. Angry that I saw an elderly woman pee her pants because she wasn’t allowed to go outside to use the bathroom. Angry because of the blatant racism and vulgar remarks. Angry because people who wanted a better life; who were willing to do slave labor, who left their countries, there homes, to be able to eat and live were treated like animals. Angry that because we didn’t speak French, the clerks yelled as if speaking louder we might understand.

                                            Maiden_name_of_carte_de_resident

When my turn came she asked my name. I gave my maiden name. Instead she typed my French married name. I had never caused a scene in my life. But on this day after being pushed to the wall, feeling the insults of the day embedded in my memory. I decided I wanted to keep my maiden name. After a blow out scene where languages collided.

The clerk stood up and ripped my document in two and pointed to the door. I won. She re-typed on a new piece of paper:

A M A R O.

*I have heard that this is the norm for immigration waiting rooms all over the world. It is not like the, "Welcome Wagon."

photos: Snippets of my French Carte de Resident. Circa 1988



Comments

57 responses to “French Immigration”

  1. Pauline Clarke

    How sad and how futile to treat each other so. When faced with so much ugliness, what can one do but present some kindess, no matter how small?

  2. mymelange

    How frustrating! But looking back, I bet it is soooo worth it! Just look where you get to live!!!

  3. “Not welcoming” is an understatement. I can see you wanting to hang on to your maiden name and sense of identity.
    It does make me wonder about the working conditions and lives of the workers there tho. Miserable would be my guess.
    I notice the bureaucratic process often seems to kill the souls of those behind the counter no matter which country they are in.
    Darla

  4. constance

    Thank you for sharing your experience Corey. Why is it that people like that lady are the way that they are? I’ve found many people who work in governmental positions like this lady you encountered. I assume she was miserable and wanted everyone to be miserable with her. ponder how negetive energy can be so powerful. It is a real achievement to stay positive and not let another persons negetive energy in! I’m glad you kept your
    Amaro!

  5. If only everyone followed the call to treat others as we ourselves would be treated.
    A very revealing collage of images (and you don’t look like a boy!).

  6. Immigration — I love the John Lennon song “Imagine” where there are no ‘countries’ or ‘borders’. We are all human beings sharing a fragile planet — why oh why do we try to keep ourselves segregated and separate? Are we so fragile that we have to use a language or a border to prove our importance.

  7. cruststation

    I love the shock expression on your b&w photo, why don’t they want a smiling face? I can tell you that I was told my picture on my ID made me look like a criminal, it’s a daunting process being in governmental buildings. Hours of queuing, papers in hand and a nervous disposition. I’m glad you stood your ground and everything turned out alright in the end!

  8. kim (via Pearl)

    Hi Corey – I married a Brit and had to go through the immigration process. I didn’t experience the harrowing ordeal that you went through but I don’t think anyone goes out of their way to welcome people into their country.
    Now that I’m living in England, my American relatives keep sending me these horrible anit-immmigration emails mostly concerned with the Mexican border. Some of the language is so distasteful that I return the emails with a note that says, “since I am now an immigrant, I don’t think you meant to send this to me.” I’d like to say something else but for the sake of family I don’t.
    Oh man… don’t get me started…
    Thanks for sharing this story. I like it that you live in France. It gives me hope that I can build a great life here in England.

  9. You go girl!! Sticking to your guns and demanding Amaro!
    I laughed when you described your picture as looking like a boy who’s about to pee her pants……
    My kids’ Passport pictures look like they where shoved up against a wall for a mug shot.
    And on the serious side, it’s a shame that people don’t treat each other with respect and compassion. Most people move to a new country make a better life for themselves and work hard to achieve that.

  10. When my Grandmother newly arrived in Canada there was her and her Mother and 2 other Sisters and none could speak English.
    She said the boat trip alone from Europe in January was terrifying as was the entrance in Canada!
    blessings.
    I love your stories
    Much love
    Jeanne

  11. shabbyinthecity

    I am with Kim (via Pearl) and I hate the emails about sending the Mexicans home and english being the language we speak here. I try to love my neighbor no matter what they speak or where they came from or how they got here.
    Did you finally get your hands on that woman’s neck?

  12. Mountain Dweller

    Unfortunately, I think immigration procedures must be the same the world over. My sister moved to the States recently and had a similar experience, despite being married to an American.

  13. Shelley Noble

    Wonderful writing about a terrible experience! Good points you make, I’ll keep them in mind.

  14. AnnieElf

    Imagine how wonderful the world would be if the process was just the opposite. For many people, what they are traveling FROM must be much worse to make going through this worth it.

  15. wishes heros

    That was not easy…

  16. This brought back memories of my immigration to the US from Canada. I guess immigration all over the world treats outsiders with suspicion. The experience really made me appreciate what people are willing to give up for a new start. We’ve since returned to Canada but I’ll remember my INS adventures forever! ♥

  17. Bossy has one question regarding the airless waiting room — Are there any other kind?

  18. What a tale, thank goodness you had the backbone to stand tall and push forward… I have heard similar stories, none with any smiles, but all with happy endings. Sometimes when we work harder to achieve our goal, the end result is worth more… I hope it was for you too!
    Corey responds:
    Off the subject…..ULLA has a wonderful gift giveaway, something she has created!! To celebrate her 750th post!! Go see, the deadline for the draw ends soon!!!

  19. It’s so sad that some people feel they can use their power so abusively. Good for you you for standing up for yourself when you were so tired and scared.

  20. Vexing for sure, but so worth it knowing at the end of the day you would return home again to Yann. 😀

  21. Ugh. No bathrooms? What?! What a stressful moment in your life, Corey. I’m so glad that everything worked out for you in the end. 🙂

  22. patpaulk

    Like cattle. government employees in whatever language are the same.

  23. Corey,
    That sounds like it was a horrible ordeal and to treat people like that is appalling.
    Interesting story – thanks for sharing. And good for you for sticking to your guns and demanding that she correct your name.
    Lorene

  24. Gypsy Purple-Chamara

    I think there is a secret world they take all government workers from certain departments globally and do something to them…..when they get out of there they have no emotion, no sympathy and no soul…..we have to find that place

  25. Alas, yes, this is a scene that unfolds all over the world. It reminded me of an equally nasty time in England when I accompanied a friend at the Home Office for her papers. I thought I’d died and gone to Hell.
    …and deliver us from the Bureaucrats…Amen.

  26. My experience wasn’t nearly as bad. It was a pain as we had to go back with different papers several times but they were mostly semi-nice. My husband was always with me which helped. If I had had to pass a test on French I would not have gotten any papers. I can hum the French national anthem but that’s it. I didn’t have to wait 8 hours at any time either. I was in Paris. Where were you?
    Corey Responds:
    Corey responds:
    In 1988 I was living in Paris, therefore I applied in Paris.
    Due to the terrorism on the Rue de Rennes (Paris,) security measures were tight and tense. No one was allowed to enter the immigration office unless they were an immigrate with an appointment and all their documents in order. It wasn’t the best of times to try to have a carte de resident not a carte de sejour.

  27. As an immigrant to Canada from the Uk, over 40 years ago I have to say I was fortunate in that my experience was the opposite. We were welcomed and made to feel at home from day one. Unfortunately I did not want to be here, and have felt since the day I arrived that I no longer belonged to either country.
    To read that immigrants are treated so badly in this day and age makes me sad. Especially when many new immigrants are so grateful to their new country for the opportunities that residents almost always take for granted.

  28. oh it is the hardest three letters here in the USA, INS.
    makes lovers weep, newlyweds cry and children crazy. your story touches a cord with me!

  29. Di Overton

    The only thing that helped Charlotte (my daughter living in Paris) was to read the book – 6 Million Frenchmen Can’t Be Wrong. The red tape and the attitude of Civil Servants still annoys her beyond belief.
    As you say about immigration it is the same the world over. Harvey and I get pulled into immigration in the US every time we visit because when we left in October 1996 the immigration people typed the wrong year in as 1995. It looked as though we had never left the year before. Each time they hold us they find this out but say they cannot change it in their system. Our bags stand outside next to the carousel just waiting for someone to steal them. No one ever apologises or even smiles.

  30. lauren Mumford

    You look terrified and stunned! So un-Coreyish… How awful for you and everyone else there. Poo on them. So glad to see you smiling now. It was obviously worth it, wasn’t it?

  31. candy.gilbert

    I can’t help but feel that even though you didn’t knowingly “do something to change the situation” just your being there, really being there in your heart had to shift the heavenlies to some degree. I imagine there is someone there who received a word or smile from you who still talks about the woman from California who touched them that day. For every action there is a reaction, Corey, and light dispells darkness every time.

  32. Blame It on Paris

    Ah, yes, immigration. Do I ever have memories of that. On both sides of the Atlantic.

  33. Petite Capucine

    It was great to read this post, I empathized with you the whole way. I loved the photos of all the paperwork; so hard won and treasured and valuable, those teeny little plastic and paper bits.
    My darling French husband has been manfully struggling to get his green card in the US for years now, and THAT BUILDING here in California is just like the one you describe, only with bathrooms. The line queuing up to fill the whole room and wind around the outside of the whole building. The number dispenser. The silent, stoic clumps of people from Russia and Vietnam and Mexico waiting out the time. The x-ray machine and the guards that won’t let you back out. It is a soul-killing place, for sure, and when we’re finally done with it, we’re having a party on the order of magnums of champagne, I think!
    And I’m with Di Overton’s comment, we always get diverted to the dreaded Second Room in US customs, too.
    And that is just on the US side! After we’ve been married for five years, then I can apply for the French green-card…and I’ll make sure I go to the bathroom at Starbucks first 😉

  34. Wow – this just makes me cringe when I think of what all my great grandparents who immigrated had to go through in Boston and New York! It is a shame, really, that something so sincere as applying for a green card should be so negative.

  35. Paris Parfait

    C’est vrai! I’ve seen and heard so many stories like this. The lack of toilet facilities is just appalling; surely that situation has improved by now. Today on the metro I saw an immigrant man give a beggar a coin – all the “locals” ignored the beggar. And yesterday it all kicked off at the Gare du Nord when someone jumped the turnstile and police tried to arrest him. All the kids from the banlieue kicked up a stir, starting fires, etc. and cursing Sarko.

  36. What a horrible experience…I guess this is the unromantic side of marrying a frenchman and moving to beautiful France…the undignified way you were all treated, especially that poor elderly lady…is disgusting. Thanks for the insight.

  37. That’s awful.

  38. Oh, Corey! I know exactly what you’re talking about. I lived in France only one year as a student in -94 (when I was 19 years old and unfortunately Finland hadn’t joined the EU yet) and had a similar experience, dealing with the French bureaucracy. I, too spent hours in the Prefecture and was turned back several times, barked at and sneered upon. Those women really knew how to scare a little fair-haired girl! When were the translations of my documents not stamped correctly and whatever else. The required medical check-ups were done in a hospital the equipment of which must have been from the 1940’s, at least the one that checked my lungs in case of tuberculosis! The doctor who took my blood test had drops of dry blood on his hands but I was too scared out of my wits to ask him to wash them first. The whole paperwork prosedure took so long that I finally received my carte de sejour just two or three months before I went back home. What was he point of that then?
    I’m so glad you stood up for youself, and I really hope things are better now. Only I fear they aren’t as French red tape still is quite famous, isn’t it? I love France but that was a humiliating experience. However, looking back, those are the sort of experiences that in their own way have shaped your life and the way you behave in difficult circumstances. And make great stories! 🙂
    Always a pleasure to look into your world!

  39. so sad the way some people treat other human beings.

  40. I am just stunned reading this from your perspective as an American entering another country. And you had the strength of spirit to stand up to the woman behind the counter. Most of those people probably would not or could not… The degrading conditions these people wanting a better life have to endure every day in these places is horrible. I wonder if the human condition will ever change….acts of compassion on the smallest level can make an impact.

  41. Kristin Wight

    This is my first post, however not my first time here! I look forward to seeing your daily entry every morning before going to work (I’m a fourth Grade teacher) It gives me focus before entering the wild world of 10 year olds… My husband, who is British, went through all the wonderful visas etc to move to the USA. We finally got engaged because the government let us!
    When we were going through the process I was amazed how difficult it was. We had trouble filling out the forms and we spoke English! I can only imagine how it feels if our native language wasn’t English!
    Everytime we move I am reminded of the process because he must let the government know where he lives. However, you do have a plus side… when traveling, we get to go through the quick line no matter what side of the Atlantic we are on! 🙂

  42. I’ve only just found your blog for the first time, but I am astounded at how similar your experience has been to the one I had trying to get a carte de séjour in Paris in 1991. I was an assistante, teaching English and I had to go back and stand in line all day long and miss teaching classes and get somebody to cover for my au pair job several times just because they changed the rules from 4 color photos and 3 black and whites to 4 black and whites and 3 in color (this is no joke) and then to something else and the people there were all so difficult and finally I just had to keep insisting that the days and times they made my appointments be other than the days and times I had to work, which was difficult at first, until I realized that the French pride trumps most things. I was able to get somewhere by asking them if they would rather I spend my time in line or spend my time teaching their precious “chères têtes blondes.” That got them to change their tune. Now that I’m a French professor, I make sure to warn my students and do some role play with them to teach them the expressions and the best ways to deal with the blank faces of the bureaucrats, but I still always think, oh the poor dears, they don’t even know. And I’ve seen first hand how it’s much the same in the U.S., except they do let you pee, but they aren’t as flexible once you figure them out and they treat you everywhere like you’re stupid and inept and not able to even sign your name. I’m glad you stood up for yourself. Thanks for this post.

  43. What an awful experience. It almost makes me want to cry. And I thought waiting at the DMV office was bad.

  44. pam aries

    What a terrible experience! Why does it have to be so ridiculouS ..It seems as if governments do not know what they are doing…oh yeah..they don’t!!!

  45. Regina Clare Jane

    Every time we travel back to the US, going through immigration is the worst part of the trip. I have been witness to miserable attitudes from immigration officers, not so much for myself or husband, but for others coming into the country- I am embarrassed for these people and ashamed as well…
    It takes so little to be nice… and I am so sorry you had such a terrible experience…

  46. DestinationMetz

    Argh! I’m getting married to a French boy, and I am not looking forward to this kind of thing…I don’t handle queues well either!

  47. What a nightmare! You could write a book about all your experiences in France Corey and I think you would be as succesful as Peter Mayle!

  48. Massilianana

    I agree , not so pleasant to go through (I am French , my husband is Swiss and we now live in Brazil) ,I speak of experience . But say , I felt I was treated this way when I arrived at NYC airport on a simple holiday trip and this was WAY before 9/11….

  49. blueVicar

    Every trip to the Prefecture is an adventure…some harrowing, some pleasant, some ordinary, but all memorable. It’s fun to read of your time there…what you felt, what you saw.
    Thanks for sharing.
    Meilleurs voeux!!
    (Oh yes, and many thanks for the link!)

  50. blueVicar

    Every trip to the Prefecture is an adventure…some harrowing, some pleasant, some ordinary, but all memorable. It’s fun to read of your time there…what you felt, what you saw.
    Thanks for sharing.
    Meilleurs voeux!!
    (Oh yes, and many thanks for the link!)

  51. Catalina

    Yes, this is a very sad reality…it happens even worst in many other places…like the United States…even just going throug inmigration when you don’t need a visa….the worst I have seen is Miami…I would say autorities are sometimes sooooooooooo impolite! People is different, I was very happily surprised some commun people here (in France) defends ilegals for example. In Venezuela (my country) is even more difficult to get a residence card or the nationality…

  52. mary jane

    Your story touched my heart. My entire family history is about such pain. I can feel your sad memories deep within my soul….hugs…

  53. simple me

    Round about the same time I was an immigrant in England … all this rings so true to me.

  54. Veronica TM

    oh, corey, this is so timely since i am filling out the application for citizenship here. i am dreading it, i remember lots of the things you are talking about here when i was applying for residency.

  55. hi corey…that is such a horrible story, heartless…brings to mind, my daughter’s best friend, married a brit, they were both chefs in nyc and started the immigration process, had to hire attorney 2000.00 to 5000.00, and then decided to visit england to meet his family after the wedding….they tried to return to nyc, when u.s. immigration asked were his stamp was that he was suppose to get u.s. side…(attorney failed to tell him to get it stamped), they wouldnt allow him to enter u.s., and he was turned away…his wife sobbed and sobbed….she tired everything in her power over the next 3 months to bring him back….all failed and she packed her bags and headed for england….bless their hearts, they were accepted….how sad it all is….but from all of it i know great things will come…..i would come armed with water, diapers, snacks, and insist my french husband comes along..(realize he couldnt), talking of these matters makes all of us aware of the pain immigrants suffer.

  56. Corey, toujours plein d’idées ! De belles images et de fabuleux trésors …

  57. Corey, your post brought tears to my eyes because I remember being in a similar siuation at the San Fracisco INS office in 1997 trying to get my husband’s residency papers. Though worlds and decades apart the story is repeated daily.
    Merci

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *