The Candy in the Middle of the Box: How to Savor the French Way

Candy box top, circa 1900s

Photos and Text by Corey Amaro:

(1988 when I first arrived in France.)

The box of assorted chocolates circled around the room. When the hostess offered her guests the box of chocolates the guests would take the chocolate closest to them without hesitation, nor reflection, as if the chocolates were all the same.

As the guests carried on with their conversation, I had one ear listening, and one eye on the hostess as she continued to offer the chocolates. I leaned to French Husband without looking obvious and asked him if it was my imagination or was it rude to select a chocolate you wanted verses taken the one closest to you when offered?

He smiled that smile that said, "We shouldn't be talking about this now." Yet he offered a quick response. Without drawing any attention to our conversation he nonchalantly said under his breath, "In France when offered a dessert, or chocolate, a glass of champagne or whatever, it is polite to accept the one closest to you."

"Really?"

"Really."

"But what if I don't want the one closest to me, but instead want the one in the middle? The white chocolate one for example?"

He gave me that look again– and then because he is ever so polite, even to the point of being rude to me, he said nothing.

bonbon bag

When the hostess offered me the box of chocolates the one closest to me was a praline. I do not like pralines. So I said no thank you and felt my mouth watering for the white chocolate one instead.

My eyes must of spoken differently than my words, because the hostess said, "You don't like chocolates? Are you sure you do not have room for a little bite?"

I tried to smile politely but as soon as I looked over at French Husband a naughty child grin came upon my face. With that I threw the French etiquette lesson over my shoulder. Then brought my hand to my lips while pinching my pointer finger and thumb together and said, "Maybe I have room for a white chocolate."

French chocolate label

As I popped the white chocolate into my mouth, sheephishly savoring the taste I looked around the room and thought who really cares?

French Husband glanced at me, and in that glance I saw more than than the white chocolate in the middle of the box. I saw that he cared.

The top of a candy box

And in a flash I learned that this new country I called home had customs, traditions, culture, attitudes…. very different from my own place of birth and that if I wanted to fit in I had to gain respect for those ways before I could adapt them.

I swallowed hard my tasty faux pas. It was the first of many small lessons that taught me that the French way is to act instead of reacting.

_______________________________

Note:

Thank your blogday wishes yesterday! I hope to open my online Tongue in Cheek Antiques within a few days. The first orders of Paper Bundles will be sent out tomorrow.



Comments

42 responses to “The Candy in the Middle of the Box: How to Savor the French Way”

  1. Life IS like a box of chocolates.
    Love you
    Jeanne
    Kisses
    Spread Joy
    Scatter Love
    I love you
    Jeanne

  2. Ida from South Africa

    Ohhh – that’s a hard lesson to learn… the best part for me is to “examine” all the chocolates and to decide which one will be my favourite for the day!

  3. Margaret Bouwmeester

    Hmmmmm somewhere there is a lesson in this, but I am like you I would want the white chocolate. There is so much to learn about the French way of life…..
    Thank you for teaching us!
    Hugs,
    Margaret B

  4. Beautiful … in so many many ways. You do it every time, Thank YOU for the memories and lessons 😉

  5. I just love this story. I often miss the framework of etiquette in this day and age as i think a few guidelines are needed. And how helpful it would be if everyone used the same ones! It certainly would add a bit of grace and gentility to life.
    Bonne anniversaire! (belatedly…)

  6. Interesting, I am still pondering that one. …Act not react….hmmm… I think I have too mush of a taste for fax pas (and chocolate) & not enough for etiquette myself!

  7. My husband, whose parents are from England and Scotland, always taught our children the same thing – when food is being passed around, take the item closest to you. I had never heard of that before I met him. So maybe it’s a European thing? It’s definitely a good manners thing! Thank you for sharing your memories!

  8. A beautiful country, beautiful antiques and beautiful manners!!! Thanks for the etiquette lesson!!

  9. Wouldn’t you have socked them all if you had picked one up and poked your finger in the bottom to see what was on the inside. It is hard learning to adapt to different cultures. My husband and I were having this conversation last night. My mother walked in the house without ringing the bell. I grew up with that and it is ok with my. She is family. My husband is German and he did not. What to do … What to do, but since it bothered him. We asked her to please knock next time.

  10. Charming story. I think I would have done the same thing!

  11. Wandering Chopsticks

    That’s how I was taught. You don’t want to appear to choose only the “best” morsels for yourself.

  12. paris impulse

    Ooooo lovely lecon
    “the French way is to act instead of reacting”
    I need to know more about that.
    Must one curb one’s American impulses?
    Food for thought…

  13. Kimberly C.

    I love your little stories – a little glimpse into the life in France. Oh how I wish I were there.

  14. I guess that does make sense to take the one closest to you, instead of the one that you want. I wonder what Emily Post has to say. I found it pretty funny that you got the white chocolate. I can’t wait to read more about French Ettiquette.

  15. carolyn parker

    Wow, that gave me shivers. thanks

  16. So many differenced in etiquette country to country. My parents told me not to take the last piece of anything, take the piece closest to you-unless you ask the host/hostess for a different piece. Mom was raised by first generation Norwegian Americans and had to curtsy and say thank you(in Norwegian) to each parent before leaving the dinner table.

  17. ohsovintage

    Pardonez moi but bugger the etiquette when chocolate is at stake!!

  18. In Australia we were always taught to take that closest. It was considered very rude to chose the best and leave the rest to others.

  19. oh, my I would not have probably picked up on that nuanced etiquette. And I too (who enjoys chocolates and rarely eats it) would have had a preference(no fruit filled chocolates for me please). But I will have to tell my step-daughter Sara about this etiquette must. She is only 11 now but after our trip last year to Paris she dreams of visiting again. And she is notorious for “her choice goes”, so when things get offered or passed around she usually peruses the bunch for her pick and will even go so far as to touch the item before it is offered. I correct her for the better in consideration of others as she grows older, but I usually chuckle a bit at her funny quirk.

  20. home before dark

    Oh the delicious moments of when choice is not a choice but a test. What a collide of two cultures. I am not sure there is enough time left in the universe for Americans (and I am one) to evolve to this kind of manners!

  21. What a difficult lesson to learn. I think I would have taken the one in the middle too. You are a better woman that myself to learn this lesson.

  22. What a delightful story. I’m betting one of the things your husband fell in love with is your ability to pick the white chocolate. It sounds like the French are very restrained. I would be so uncomfortable in that kind of society. Linda

  23. Kathleen in Oregon

    The best part is FH cared more about your well being than his own embarrassment.
    It’s funny though, when they pass the tray of pastries don’t you get to pick the kind you like?

  24. jend’isère

    The closest appears to be the most correct, regardless the culture. Everyone is polite with the LazySusan turning plateau found on Chinese tables.

  25. Julie Ann Evins

    When in France….I am sure Yann had the proverbial “Tongue in Cheek” during the choc faux pas and would love you a whole ocean even had you eaten the whole box ! Luv Jx

  26. roxane stoner

    You have the advantage of being the foreigner and will be excuse for the faux pas so continue to take advantage as long as you can… The hard custom I have to deal in the USA is to keep my left hand on my lap when I eat. I grew up having to show both my hands on the top of the table. Something that I still struggle with after 27 years. Another one is to ask for what you want at the table instead of it being offered to you or not getting it for yourself as not to disturb the conversation or the people around you.

  27. Well, the pictures are pretty even when you’re telling a story about being naughty.

  28. I love this Story, other countries traditions are always so interesting. I love hearing about the christmas traditions.
    congrats on four years of blogging carey

  29. Um, he took you to a nude beach on your second date, but frowned on your choice of chocolates? …oh, those French!!

  30. Shelley Noble

    I must be an American savage! I would never conform to any custom for politeness’ sake! I better stay here!

  31. Ariane Cagle

    I find all the lessons in customs, traditions, and culture very interesting. Plus I’m learning everything I did wrong when I visited France back when I was 19. No wonder my sponsor family was not that nice to me, they must have thought I was a barbarian. Can you tell me is it rude in France to count your change when leaving the Metro ticket kiosk? I got royally yelled at for doing that and I didn’t understand why — partly because the ticket person was speaking so fast I didn’t understand what she was saying.
    Happy blog anniversary! I love reading your blog!

  32. I laughed at Shelley Noble’s remark about “American savage”. I feel like that’s what the rest of the world must think of us.
    I would fail the chocolate taking test. I would hem and haw causing the hostess to wait until I made up my mind.
    Good luck with your new store! Tongue In Cheek Antiques is an excellent name 🙂

  33. this is how i was taught too. this is a European thing. i teach my son the same. american culture is more liberated but i actually like old Europe etiquette. i think lot of it is changing now since the world is getting smaller 🙂

  34. No I don’t know what it means….I stay ever evolving gray because i don’t want to spend the time or money, I cut my own hair. That said….Corey, you look delicious blonde, absolutely lovely.

  35. For what it is worth…your faux pas was entirely forgiveable.
    At least I think it was. It was a teachable moment 🙂
    And since, I’m sure you’ve taught the French a thing or two.
    xo

  36. I can totally relate to this experience. Only mine was the reverse. Coming from Portugal, where we were served lunch restaurant style, with only four students per table. Plates stacked three high, formal flatware,tablecloth and cloth napkins. I was horrified when I entered the cafeteria of my American high school. The noise was deafening. Food literally flying across the room with endless tables and plastic trays.
    For fear of offending someone, I will not say what I thought of the behavior of the students who seemed more like hooligans in the midst of a riot.
    I can still hear the roar of the kids when I stood up as we did in Portugal when the teacher entered the room. The only saving grace was that I did not speak English.

  37. Dear Corey,
    Your insights and stories continue to enthrall me.
    hugs,
    Gail

  38. An incredible retelling of that moment… thank you for sharing your gifts with us. Your story has given me a long pause. And I need another example of the french way of “act instead of reacting.”

  39. I think etiquette should be a matter of common sense. I don’t see the sense in offering someone something and not expecting them to select what they would like. The point should be to want your guest to feel comfortable. I’m sure there was someone in the room who would have wanted the Praline as much as you wanted the white chocolate. JMHO
    ~elaine~

  40. I just read Maria’s comment and laughed out loud.
    ~elaine~

  41. I am a chocaholic and would probably have been so nervous being the only American in the room that I wouldn’t have even noticed what everyone else was doing. You were observant and I admire that quality. What really touched me about your story, however, was that French husband cared – and that you knew he cared. I’ll be that was sweeter than the white chocolate.

  42. Good things come to those who wait & even better things come to those who say “no”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *