French Immigration…Residence Card

                   French immigration residence card

 

Like other foreigners who are living in France, I had to go through the French immigration process to have my carte de resident (Residence Card.) Because I was married to a Frenchman, the paperwork to receive residence in France, was considered more of a formality than a daunting procedure to be legal in the country. Nevertheless, it was a real eye opening experience, and one that haunts me when I hear about immigration….

 

                   Resident_carte

 

With my back-pack full of legal French documents and less than ten French words in my pocket, I went to the Prefecture in Paris to apply for my residence card.

Standing in line, waiting with hundreds of other immigrants, I realized I was not alone in feeling nervous. My eyes searched the crowd for a friend, someone who I might shot the breeze with….but without a common language between us we could only share a small smile of encouragement.

 

                   French_papers

 

There was a guard at the entrance door. She grabbed my papers, and started to bark something in French. I didn't know what she was saying. Luckily I understand her sign language, as she pointed to the photo machine. I needed a black and white, non-smiling photo of myself. Not a happy one, in color like I had in hand. (Look at the photo of me up above: Wide-eyed, boyish… someone who is about to wet her pants.)

 

                   French_carte_de_resident

 

Walking into the small airless waiting room I saw the whole world gathered. Fourteen chairs for a few hundred people. No water, not bathroom. There were elderly people, young people, pregnant women and small children. I stood there wishing I could do something to change the situation. Each of us had a number and waited our turn. After waiting eight hours my turn finally arrived. The clerk, who looked like she had never smiled in her entire life, looked at me like I was a murderer trying to ask for a knife. It wasn't easy.

I felt angry. Angry that people should treat people as rudely as I had seen in the last eight hours. Angry that I saw an elderly woman pee her pants because she wasn't allowed to go outside to use the bathroom. Angry because of the blatant racism and vulgar remarks. Angry because people who wanted a better life; who were willing to do slave labor,who left their countries, there homes, to be able to eat and live were treated like animals. Angry that because we didn't speak French, the clerks yelled as if speaking louder we might understand.

 

                                            carte_de_resident

 

When my turn came the clerk asked my name. I gave my name. Not understanding me, she huffed as she ramaged through my paperwork then typed my married name.

I had never caused a scene in my life. But on this day after being pushed to the wall, feeling the insults of the day embedded in my memory. I decided I wanted to keep my maiden name. After a blow out scene where languages collided.

The clerk stood up and ripped my document in two . Then she re-typed on a new piece of paper:

A M A R O.

I won.

*I have heard that this is the norm for immigration waiting rooms all over the world. It is not like the "Welcome Wagon."

Photos: Snippets of my French Carte de Resident. Circa 1988

 



Comments

20 responses to “French Immigration…Residence Card”

  1. Christine

    Wow, what a disheartening experience. I’ve never understood why government workers in general, everywhere, often treat their customers so unkindly. The only reason to me seems that they must be very unhappy souls. So sad.

  2. 4:00 am in a long line in front of a Canadian Immigration office in Toronto IN JANUARY. Dark, freezing. The office opened at 8:30 am. Once inside, they did have a toilet :-).

  3. Corey, It is consistent no matter where you go. I have a very similar story to tell from my experience with my husband’s immigration application. After 3 years of humiliation, multiple trips to the immigration office and being 7 month pregnant and being told that my husband would have to leave the country(unbelievable, still), I finally called my senator’s office only to learn that they had LOST MY HUSBAND’S FILE! We had to start over again!!!
    Now I spend my spare time volunteering to assist asylum seekers and victims of human trafficking. They have already been to hell and don’t need to go again in the immigration office.

  4. Jeannette StG

    Haven’t been here for a while, because we also connected on FB (Jesh StGermain )-
    have to tell you something disappointing – it’s not much better in other countries, including the US! I spare you our green card and visa experiences in the US -not better? No, sorry, not better.

  5. martina

    Even if a person is having a bad day, they should not take it out on the people they are hired to assist. The staff for the City of Seattle are in general extraordinarily good at customer service. They coud teach government agencies good manners.

  6. Lana Kloch

    no wonder you were missing in action! wish it could have been under better circumstances. hove you have recovered. thanks for sharing this side of peoples’ inhumane treatment. we often take it for granted.

  7. parisbreakfast

    WOW
    What a story.
    There be so many stories in that room.
    When I saw yr post I started to tear up.
    I want to ’emigrate’ or do something or other so I can LIVE in France.
    On the Security line at JFK coming over this time, I started talking to an attractive French family about NYC, shopping etc.
    They asked me was my trip to Paris a vacation?
    I stupidly blurted out I was going to talk to a lawyer about emigrating (she cost $450 an hr so that didn’t excatly work out).
    They immediately turned their backs and never spoke another word to me.
    Very tricky subject oui…

  8. jend’isère

    Among the immigration stories, I have a tale relating to your subject. My first French immigration experience was in a huge immigration center near Notre Dame. Since toilets do tend to call during stressful moments, I tangled my handbag, filed papers and pantyhose with high heels around myself to keep dry. A Turkish squat variety that intensified my experience as feeling like a foreigner.

  9. meredith

    I saw some not very nice stuff while going through this process. Examples of big discrimination between me, a white person and another woman, of North African origins. She needed change for a new ID photo, and the lady at the desk at the Prefecture wouldn’t give it to her. I was next in line and I needed change for my ID photo too. And she gave it to me. I felt very bad for the African woman in front of me, but after waiting so many hours, I didn’t offer up my change…I really got the run-around while trying to get my paper-work in order. Many times I came home crying. And it was supposedly easy for me, being married to a Frenchman. I’m glad I’m french now and will never have to go through that again. And I hope that the process will be made more humane for those going through the process now…

  10. Having 4 kids from China, I understand the experience with sad memories of my own. I was shocked at the level of dismissive rudeness I witnessed the day we waited (in an airless room) in Boston for 8 hours. Finally someone came out to address the crowd…”We close at 4:30, you’ll have to come back tomorrow.” No one would stand up to the bullies (and they were bullies) I suppose because they feared retribution of the worst sort, being thrown out of the country or paperwork and files being mysteriously lost.
    It pushed me to the edge!
    I stood up and said “That is unexceptable, I want to speak to your supervisor.” I did not sit down until the supervisor came out. I told him that as a tax paying citizen I was ashamed at what I saw and experienced and that I was going to write to my senator (at the time Ted Kennedy.) Everyone in the room was processed that day.

  11. Corey, I can still feel for you so many years later but in truth, I feel for those millions of immigrants all over the world who until this day, continue to be insulted and dehumanized just to have what is a human right; to live a good life with hope and respect. Immigration is a hot topic, as you know, here in the US – and I often want to shake people and say “AND WHERE ARE YOUR GRANDPARENTS FROM”. I know half of mine are from Germany and I am sad that they went through that to give ME a better life. Thanks for sharing what are surely painful memories. Ruth

  12. labergerebasque

    When I worked for a well known French airline at LAX (about 12 years agp) I oftentimes was required to do some translating in immigration. I will never forget one of my first such experiences when an 8 month old baby boy was taken from his mother’s arms (baby had an American passport and father) because her passport was polish and the officer was sure she would stay illegally in the US … She was “jailed” and re-booked on the next flight back via Paris. She was denied US entry and because “immigration” is neutral territory no lawyers may be called.
    The screaming baby was handed over to the father who was waiting for the mother.
    The next flight was the next day and she was brought forth in handcuffs. The father paid full fare to go back with her, claiming he wanted nothing more to do with a country who would treat a mother and child this way. True story
    I could tell you some hideous immigration stories even from so called “exemplary civil rights” countries

  13. I am an immigrant myself, and always try to be nice to immigrants. I know what it feels like, to be in between two worlds.

  14. Annie v.

    When I married my first husband who was american, and me french, well that also was an ordeal!!!!. needed a police report, had to go to the american embassy in Paris where women were all made to strip in front of each other for a health check up, this was in 1960, the horror of it I was 18 years old, plus a ton of other papers were needed, to this day I have not forgotten the humiliation, needless to say I also a horror of bureaucrats..
    Annie v.

  15. Had my US green card experience. Agree, no better. I’m still very agree when thinking about it.

  16. I only have positive words for Immigration people in Hong Kong though. They talk to you with respect, they are very efficient in their work. Never make you feel a second class person, a beggar.
    HK is my third place (country) of living, after my native Ukraine and then the US, and it is the BEST!

  17. herhimnbryn

    Oh Corey what Hell.
    I must say that my experience in Australia was pleasant. Husband came with me, the staff were polite and approachable and there were lavatories!

  18. Stubblejumpin Gal (Kate)

    I’ve been doing a lot of web-searching (for work) in recent weeks for images of refugees, and in the doing have naturally done quite a bit of reading, and it has been a real eye-opener about the plight of refugees in this world, and the reasons they leave their birth countries, and the situations they find themselves in, and the state of being stateless, and the laws in regard to them in all the countries that accept refugees. So … you were not a refugee … but even immigrants have a bunch of B.S. added unnecessarily to their stress! It has given me a respect for Angelina Jolie and other celebrities who, instead of sitting on their duffs (as they could certainly afford to do), are out there trying to make a difference for some of these people, probably having their hearts broken many times in the process just by seeing what there is to see.

  19. Melissa Paruzel

    Wow, reading that made me ponder the possibility of ever wanting to live in my husband’s country! Not only I barely know the language, I don’t even understand certain things they do there. I already detested the immigration officers there, so I don’t think migrating there would be easy. The red tapes were so tangled over there, it made my country’s red tape so simple.
    My husband just got his residence pass – he said it took him roughly 2 hours to be in the queue. He waited 1 month for the acceptance process. Then today, he was accepted and next week he will have to pick up the pass. He is pretty happy since he liked it here. He even said that the retiree fund system here is more efficient than his home.

  20. Reading this I realized how very blessed I am over here in Japan. I remember one bad scene at the immigration office in Tokyo (an officer was yelling at an elderly Chinese couple that obviously couldn’t understand what he was saying). Other than that I have never witnessed any kind of abuse or rudeness at a Japanese immigration office. Some workers may be a little expressionless, but not rude. The last time I had to go all of the workers were so kind and cheerful that I left feeling like maybe I had not been in the immigration office at all!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *