The Chocolate in the Middle of the Box

Candy box top, circa 1900s

Photos and Text by Corey Amaro:

(1988 when I first arrived in France.)

 

The box of assorted chocolates circled around the room. When the hostess offered her guests the box of chocolates the guests would take the chocolate closest to them without hesitation, nor reflection, as if the chocolates were all the same.

As the guests carried on with their conversation, I had one ear listening, and one eye on the hostess as she continued to offer the chocolates. I leaned to French Husband without looking obvious and asked him if it was my imagination or was it rude to select a chocolate you wanted verses taken the one closest to you when offered?

He smiled that smile that said, "We shouldn't be talking about this now." Yet he offered a quick response. Without drawing any attention to our conversation he nonchalantly said under his breath, "In France when offered a dessert, or chocolate, a glass of champagne or whatever, it is polite to accept the one closest to you."

"Really?"

"Really."

"But what if I don't want the one closest to me, but instead want the one in the middle? The white chocolate one for example?"

He gave me that look again– and then because he is ever so polite, even to the point of being rude to me, he said nothing.

 

bonbon bag 

When the hostess offered me the box of chocolates the one closest to me was a praline. I do not like pralines. So I said no thank you and felt my mouth watering for the white chocolate one instead.

My eyes must of spoken differently than my words, because the hostess said, "You don't like chocolates? Are you sure you do not have room for a little bite?"

I tried to smile politely but as soon as I looked over at French Husband a naughty child grin came upon my face. With that I threw the French etiquette lesson over my shoulder. Then brought my hand to my lips while pinching my pointer finger and thumb together and said, "Maybe I have room for a white chocolate."

 

French chocolate label 

As I popped the white chocolate into my mouth, sheephishly savoring the taste I looked around the room and thought who really cares?

French Husband glanced at me, and in that glance I saw more than than the white chocolate in the middle of the box. I saw that he cared.

 

The top of a candy box 

And in a flash I learned that this new country I called home had customs, traditions, culture, attitudes…. very different from my own place of birth and that if I wanted to fit in I had to gain respect for those ways before I could adapt them.

I swallowed hard my tasty faux pas. It was the first of many small lessons that taught me that the French way is to act instead of reacting.



Comments

17 responses to “The Chocolate in the Middle of the Box”

  1. What a lovely tale – thank you for sharing.

  2. La Contessa

    LOVE IT!Was in Santa Barbara this weekend with relatives and somehow YOU came up as I have a cousin who follows you too!She loves the way you write!As I do too!See you soon…I hope!

  3. When I was in France recently, living with a host family, I tried so hard to remember all the French etiquette lessons you have shared. Oh, gosh, might have failed on this one. No worries – loved acting French 98% of the time!

  4. Even after several trips to the Azores, I still worry re committing some social faux pas or other that will cause the locals to think to themselves, “Oh, she’s SUCH an Americana!” (and not necessarily in a good way, either). About the only tip I can offer is never to go first, so that way you can copy what the natives do (within the limits of good sense, of course).

  5. This is a wonderful story and lesson. While reading it, I thought I probably would have grabbed any two chocolates that I wanted, if there were plenty in the box. Eek.

  6. Sharon Mattern

    I like that your husband could communicate with a caring look. Rodger and I can say so much to each other with a glance, a nod or a gleam in the eye!
    Great post Corey!

  7. loved this post Corey!! Thanks for your well written and creative posts!! bisous et calins

  8. It’s not easy fitting in in a new place. Takes time to learn and adjust, even in your own country which you left for many years. It’s interesting how small things or gestures can be read or regarded differently in different cultures.

  9. LOL! I respect honesty. Yours made tea go down wrong. Am still laughing around the coughs.

  10. Okay, but what if you are allergic to nuts? Hmm. 🙂 Couldn’t resist. Plus, you declined, so why were you put into such a position by the hostess? I’d have gotten that white chocolate, too, Corey. 🙂 Life might be like a box of chocolates, but eating a praline when you don’t like them is a little like lying, isn’t it? Obeying protocol isn’t everything. Am willing to bet more than one of those women guests wished they’d done a Corey. 😉

  11. Shelley Noble

    I couldn’t do it, Corey! I could never ever stifle my crude ways. My ways are crude even by American standards!
    I want what I want, and couldn’t care less what the hostess wanted. Guess I’d better stay in the states.
    🙂

  12. Thanks for sharing this story.

  13. Heather Lindstrom

    Oh Corey,
    You are so expressive….have such a way with the words (and the chocolates!) I am drawn into every ‘bite’. The French way to ‘act’ not to react…..perfection.
    I must study up since we will be in London and Paris this year for Christmas holiday with family.
    Cheers Corey-you are a local girl made good.
    xo Heather

  14. Marie-Noëlle

    Hm, hm … I’m French … (whispering) and I would have taken the one in the middle, had I been keen on white chocolates (Sorry, FH!)
    Fortunately, I like only “Mon Chéri” chocolates, which usually come round by rows in their boxes… so the closest to me is always my favourite one!!!

  15. I think that must be the hardest part about being married to a Frenchman — being with someone who cares if you don’t conform. Of course, there are Americans like that too. I hope you continue to choose the white chocolate when it suits you.

  16. marvellous post Corey. French etiquette is one thing I shall never totally understand because on the one side there are a millions rules of how to behave and on the other side I have found the Parisian French amongst the most selfish, careless and badly behaved poeple I’ve ever met. I have been raised and observe the simple rules of consideration of the next, of being modest when being offered something and then I let my judment rule. So, if you only like white chocs (eek! :)), I can’t see why you shouldn’t say: May I take a white one (as you did so charmingly when asked about a place for one choc… – loved that reply!!!!) please and I wd like to see a hostess who’d say: No, you can’t have that – take the nearest to you…..
    I have also never found in any of the countries I lived in so many UNSPOKEN rules of ‘good behavour’ – and it only ‘hit’ me in Paris, but never in Provence, Luberon, Normandy, Brittany and along the West Coast of France. But it might well be that I didn’t meet the ‘real, real’ French on my very many travels because I didn’t live here. With the Americans at least you know where you stand even if they might be considered too forward to many of the ‘old Europeans’. I don’t know; but it’s an interesting subject.
    Have a good week with many white chocolates. I wd love to send you a box with just the white ones and I’d keep all the black ones…. and then we could play games until they’re all eaten! Oh, the fun we wd have.

  17. Massilianana

    Very funny post Corey, as lively as a little movie ( i bet you could be a very good screenplay writer or even director). But honestly, are we really that à cheval on those rules ???

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *